Why Do I Always Focus on the Negative? Understanding the Mental Filter Trap

Overthinking 101 - part 5 of 11

Table of Contents

Mental filtering narrows your focus to the negatives, like seeing only one part of the picture while missing the rest.

This is the fifth post in the Overthinking 101 series, and it's all about one of the most common negative thinking habits: the mental filter, sometimes called a 'glass half empty' mindset, which leads us to focus on negatives while ignoring positives, often without even realising it.

What Is Mental Filtering? Understanding the Glass Half Empty Mindset

If you've ever asked yourself, "Why do I always focus on the negatives?", then you could be stuck in the classic glass-half-empty mentality, a form of negative mindset where your brain filters out the good and magnifies what went wrong.

Perhaps you might have had lots of praise from your boss at work, but you find that you can only focus on one piece of criticism of the report you turned in.

Or maybe you had a lovely day out with your friends, but your main memory is of the ten minutes that it rained.

And what about the time when you cooked a perfect Sunday roast, except for the slightly overdone broccoli that went a bit mushy, and you felt like you failed, even though everyone enjoyed the meal.

Mental filtering is a common thinking trap, which is rooted in the brain's natural negativity bias.

It’s sometimes also called emotional filtering, because of the way our feelings reinforce the parts of reality we pay attention to.

Whether you call it mental filtering, emotional filtering, or just “spiralling,” the effect is the same: a narrowing of perspective that can leave you feeling stuck and discouraged, focusing on what's wrong and overlooking the positives in a situation.

Same glass, different outlooks: the classic ‘glass half empty’ mindset shapes our emotional reality.

It's a glass-half-empty perspective, where the positive parts of an experience fade into the background, and the flaws take centre stage.

Think of the mental filter as being like wearing dark-tinted glasses, we may not even realise that we’re wearing them until we pause and take them off.

It’s a classic case of focusing on the negative, even when the full picture is more balanced than it feels in that moment.

The glass-half-empty syndrome affects how we process experiences, so learning how to stop focusing on negative thoughts is essential for our mental well-being.

This kind of mental 'tunnel vision' can quietly feed anxiety, frustration, or a sense of hopelessness, often without us even realising.

Why do our brains do this to us?

Sticking to the bad stuff like Velcro, while letting the good stuff slide off like Teflon.

Mental filtering in action: our brains tend to stick to criticism like Velcro but let compliments slide off like Teflon.

The strange thing is, this is your brain trying to help, rather than hinder you. It's trying to protect you.

Unfortunately, it can get a bit overzealous and stuck on 'danger mode', which leaves you fixating on bad things, even when they're only a very small part of the picture.

So if you're wondering, 'How do I stop obsessing over negative thoughts?', then understanding this brain mechanism is key to being able to start addressing it.

Why Does My Brain Always Focus on the Negatives? Understanding the Negativity Bias

When we're getting caught up in the mental filtering trap, our brains are operating in 'better-safe-than-sorry' mode.

We have our ancestors to thank for this! Those of them who quickly spotted dangers (predators, poisonous plants, hostile tribes) were more likely to survive and pass on their genes.

Each and every one of us alive today is here because the line of ancestors before us was successful enough to pass on their genes.

They were expert worriers and spotted threats quickly, enabling them to take action to protect themselves.

Those who focused on positives and ignored warning signs often didn't live long enough to reproduce.

So this means that we've naturally inherited a tendency to be alert to danger.

The problem is that the things we perceive as dangerous in the modern world aren't the kinds of problems that the system evolved to tackle, so it can leave us caught in cycles of distress when we get trapped in an unhelpful thinking habit about whether the broccoli was too soggy or not.

This is a classic example of our negativity bias feeding into a negative mindset, even when the actual risk is minimal.

Negativity bias works like a mental loop: the more we focus on the negative, the more we reinforce it.

Our ancient survival mechanism ends up working against us in the relative safety of today's world, with all the comforts and benefits of modern technology.

Our self-preservation system sees social rejection, work failures, or minor imperfections as being as dangerous; that critical email from your boss is indistinguishable from the saber-toothed tiger that our ancestors were worrying about.

This is what Psychologists call 'negativity bias' in action.

Our brains are wired to pay far more attention to negative information than positive, because historically, that kept people safe.

Mental filtering is one way this negativity bias shows up in daily life, making small issues feel disproportionately important.

The mental filter becomes like a smoke detector that screams at you every time you make toast; it's technically doing its job, but after a while, it's just creating lots of stress.

Bad experiences stick in our memories much more strongly than good ones, because the knowledge from the bad experience might come in handy for saving our lives at some point in the future.

Sadly, though, this means that we can remember a throw-away criticism for years, while positive feedback quickly evaporates from our memories.

But once we realise that this isn't a character flaw in ourselves, rather it is an evolutionary hangover, we can start to respond with curiosity instead of self-criticism.

It's not your fault!

What personality types see the glass as half empty?

The mental filter is commonly experienced by detail-oriented people and high achievers.

These are people who are excellent at spotting flaws and inconsistencies.

While they may use criticism as a motivator, unfortunately, it can end up counterproductive because they get stuck focusing on what's not good enough.

Perfectionists and highly sensitive people tend to process information more deeply, which means that they spot details that others might miss.

This can also lead to emotional filtering, where their strong feelings, like disappointment or worry, colour how the situation is remembered.

Anyone who is prone to anxiety is susceptible to mental filtering, as they are naturally scanning for potential problems much more than someone who isn't anxious.

Traits such as perfectionism, deep emotional processing, and anxiety often overlap to create a glass-half-empty mindset, but these traits also come with powerful strengths!

But it's important to realise that absolutely anyone can experience the glass-half-empty perspective, regardless of their personality type.

It's more a case of being about learned patterns and stress levels than fixed personality traits...even naturally optimistic people can slip into mental filtering traps during difficult and challenging times.

It's also worth noting that these traits often come with significant strengths: attention to detail, high standards, and empathy.

So the goal isn't to try to change your personality, rather it is to recognise when the mental filter is a hindrance rather than a help.

How to Recognise When You're Filtering Out the Positives (Spotting Mental and Emotional Filtering)

To learn how to stop fixating on negative thoughts, as with the other thought traps, the first (and perhaps most difficult) step is to actually notice that you are doing it in the first place.

Start by noticing the emotional tone of your thoughts coming to mind; are they skewed towards the negative?

That’s often one of the first signs of mental filtering or emotional filtering in action, and could mean you’re unintentionally filtering out the more positive parts of the experience.

Your feelings might be guiding your focus: a classic example of emotional filtering, where what we feel starts to shape what we notice and creates a cycle of negative focus.

You might also notice physical sensations: tension, heaviness, or that familiar sinking feeling that comes with dwelling on problems.

Mental filtering often shows up in small, everyday moments.

After a social event, you might find your mind replaying that one awkward moment that made you feel really uncomfortable.

Instead of remembering the many warm conversations and smiles, you remember how your stomach lurched and you got that cold feeling all over.

That’s negativity bias quietly shaping your memory.

How to Reframe a Negative Mindset When You're Noticing the Mental Filter

Most situations can be seen from more than one angle, even those that feel overwhelmingly negative to us.

Reframing how we see a situation won’t change what happened, but it does change how we experience what happened, which can make a massive difference to how we feel about it.

These small shifts aren’t about denying the bad bits, they’re about making space for the good bits as well and easing the emotional weight we give to minor setbacks.

Here are three gentle ways to reframe your perspective when you catch yourself focusing only on the negative:

These questions help you step back and look at the situation, rather than from the situation, giving you the chance to see new perspectives.

Remember the Sunday roast?

Rather than 'The broccoli was soggy, the meal was ruined', reframe that thought as 'I cooked a meal that was delicious overall, and everyone enjoyed it'.

With time, curiosity, and compassion, you can teach your brain to overcome the mental filter and notice the balanced perspective, not just the negativity.

The key is to actively look at the full picture rather than sticking to the mental filter's narrow focus.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting that you are unrealistic about a situation or suggesting that you ignore problems, it is simply about seeing situations more completely.

It’s like taking off those dark-tinted glasses, so that you can see what’s really there, not just what went wrong.

Processing Thoughts: A Practical Exercise for Mental Clarity

Some people find it a helpful exercise to write down what they are noticing as a way of processing it.

You can ask yourself the following questions to help:

• What was the situation?
  

• What thoughts do you notice?
  

• What feelings travel alongside those thoughts?
  

• What aspects of the situation are you discounting?
  

• What’s a more balanced view?
  

• What feelings go with this new balanced view?
  

These questions can help you step back and gently shift your perspective, especially when your brain feels stuck on one bad moment.

Rewiring these habits is less like flipping a switch and more like planting a new path through a field; at first, it’s overgrown and hard to spot, but with each gentle step, it becomes clearer.

Changing the Way You Think: Why Practice and Self-Kindness Go Hand in Hand

Learning how to stop mental filtering takes time and patience.

The more you practise processing your thoughts this way, the easier it becomes, but only if you remember to show yourself some kindness along the way.

Practice and self-kindness go hand in hand and, together, they lead the way to more balanced, compassionate thinking.

Compassion is a key factor when learning any new skill; you’re not meant to master it overnight, and it's inevitable that there will be wobbles and wrong turns along the way.

These ups and downs are part of growth. Remember, even recognizing when you're stuck in mental filtering is progress worth celebrating.

When we respond with self-compassion instead of self-criticism, we give ourselves the conditions we need to grow.

This is how you train your brain to stop fixating on negative thoughts, through consistent, kind practice.

Compassion isn’t a soft option (as some people think it is), it’s the tool that helps you change the lens you’re looking through so that you're not just seeing the bits that went wrong.

When your mental filter defaults to criticism, self-kindness is like adjusting the focus, not to blur out the hard bits, but to see the whole scene more clearly.

The next time you find yourself dwelling on the overcooked broccoli instead of the perfect roast, remember to adjust your focus with kindness.

This article is one part of a series tackling unhelpful thinking patterns that can contribute to anxiety and low self-esteem, along with a host of other challenges such as stress, overwhelm, and low mood.

To find out about the other common thinking traps, you can explore the full 'Overthinking 101' series by following the links below:

Critical Self  - the tendency to paint ourselves in the least flattering of lights

Black & White Thinking  - the tendency to see things in extremes, with no space for nuance...a situation is either a complete success or a total failure

Overgeneralising  - the tendency to take one negative event and extrapolate it to everything

Mountains & Molehills  - the tendency to magnify negatives and minimise positives

Mind Reading  - the tendency to assume that we know what other people are thinking, and usually then assuming it's something negative

Catastrophising  - the tendency to assume the worst possible outcome will happen, even in situations where it's not very likely

Shoulds & Musts  - the tendency to hold ourselves to unrealistic expectations and rules, that invariably set us up for failure

Judgements & Labelling - the tendency to attach negative labels to ourselves and others based on isolated events

Emotional Reasoning  - the tendency to believe that our emotions are an accurate representation of the reality of a situation

Glossary: Not Sure What Something Means?

Some of the phrases I've used are CBT classics; helpful once you know them, confusing if you don’t. Here’s a quick explainer:

Mental Filtering	A type of unhelpful thinking habit where you focus exclusively on the negatives in a situation, filtering out anything positive. Often linked to anxiety, low mood, and overthinking.
Negativity Bias	The brain’s natural tendency to pay more attention to negative experiences than positive ones. This evolved to keep us safe, but can lead to emotional imbalance in everyday life.
Negative Mindset	A habitual pattern of thinking that emphasises flaws, failures, or potential dangers. Often fuelled by cognitive distortions like mental filtering and catastrophising.
Emotional Filtering	A subset of mental filtering where your current mood shapes what you notice and remember. For example, feeling anxious might cause you to zoom in on potential problems and ignore positives.
Cognitive Bias	A biased way of thinking that skews how you interpret the world, often leading to increased anxiety or low self-esteem. Mental filtering is one of many common cognitive distortions.
Glass Half Empty Mentality	A pessimistic mindset where you consistently focus on what's lacking, wrong, or negative in situations rather than the positive aspects. It leads to interpreting ambiguous or mixed situations in the worst possible light, even when there are clear benefits or successes present.
Reframing	A CBT technique that involves consciously changing your perspective on a situation to see it more completely or positively. Rather than changing what happened, reframing changes how you interpret and experience the event, which can significantly improve your emotional response and overall well-being.

FAQ: Mental Filtering and Negative Thought Patterns

What does mental filtering mean in psychology?

Why do I always focus on the negatives?

What personality types tend to have glass-half-empty thinking?

How do I stop overthinking and focus on the positives?

What is ‘glass half empty’ syndrome?

How can I overcome mental filtering and negative thought loops?

If your mind still feels like a battleground, that’s okay. Many people feel the same.

Support is within reach.

---

About the author: Sarah Cosway is a BABCP-accredited Cognitive Behavioural Psychotherapist with over a decade of experience working in mental health both within the NHS and in private practice. She offers tailored CBT in a compassionate, collaborative environment, empowering clients to build resilience and manage their mental wellbeing with confidence.

https://www.coswaycbt.co.uk

---

Enjoyed this post and found it helpful? Please spread the word!

Share it with friends, colleagues, or anyone else who might find it valuable. Your support helps grow my community and keeps the conversation going.

Stay in the loop! Sign up for notifications below and never miss a new post.

I respect your inbox—no spam, just fresh content delivered straight to you. Join my community of readers today!